Jump to content

WWI Robbins large batwing residue on reverse?


Recommended Posts

Flightwings
Posted

I've noticed this a couple times so far and I think on non maker marked Robbins wings. At first I thought it was sticker glue, but Chris suggested it could be solder from a metal tag? Anyone seen this before. I've seen it twice that I can come up with. Could it be from some retailer marking that a store would put on a non maker marked wing to sell as their own? Curious if anyone has seen one with the original sticker or tag on the back? Any thought appreciated. (images from internet) I have not had either in hand, so can't say for myself.

 

Gerard

 

 

image000002.jpg

s-l1600-49 copy.jpg

rathbonemuseum.com
Posted

Have not seen one with a tag. Just the 'bump'. Could also be a function of the original forcer and the way it strikes the metal.

rathbonemuseum.com
Posted

Or another possible idea, a bit of solder to hold the wing in place while finishing was taking place.

Posted

In a previous thread, Russ posted a composite picture of 4 Robbins-marked and unmarked wings. None of them has that "smudgy" thing on the back.


My opinion is that the addition of a small "plaque" with a maker's name is, more often than not, an artifact of the faker trying to fool collectors.  Not that it means anything, but I have never really seen a WWI wing with one of those plaques that I thought was legit, in any case (e.g., the Le Breve Paris fakes).

 

I have NEVER seen a Robbins plaque on any wing, much less a WWI pilot wing.

 

Other than blaming Gremlins, I have no idea what or why those smudges are.

 

IMG_1926.jpeg.450e468c81b6c06067bd062871f6a0c0.jpeg.522c2998cc9e52a65f51ad5c2cdf02a4.jpeg

 

Posted

Here's a similar wing to Gerard's with the mysterious smudgy thing on the back. I always assumed this was done to cover up the sterling mark. Maybe they were made in silver?

 

Bob

WW1RobbinsWingBckLR.jpg

rathbonemuseum.com
Posted

Good theory

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...