Jump to content

USMC Banana Wars: Help Dating Photo


Recommended Posts

world war I nerd

I just received this photo, which was described as "Marines guarding prisoners, Vera Cruz, Mexico."

 

Based on the fact that the Marines are wearing lift-the-dot cartridge belts and are armed with Enfield rifles and bayonets, the image must date to WWI or maybe post WW I.

 

Written in ink (fountain pen) on the reverse of the postcard is: "Marines guarding prisoners from the fort whom we made do much of our work."

 

Does the inscription provide any clues as to when and where this image was taken?

 

Looking forward to hearing from the hard-core USMC collectors.

 

Thanks for looking. World War I Nerd ...

post-5143-0-92368100-1533679730_thumb.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

world war I nerd

And the Enfield rifles and bayonets and scabbard ...

 

I can't tell if they have lift-the-dot canteen covers or not?

post-5143-0-55634200-1533679889_thumb.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

world war I nerd

I thought It might help if I added a close-up of the men under guard. My guess is that they are Haitian?

post-5143-0-24099700-1533680381_thumb.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Lift the dot snaps (~1918) and M1917 rifles (also ~1918) and bayonets argue for late 1917 or later. This photo dates to at least after the Marines received those items.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Marchville1918

I agree with the comment above. The rifles and web gear indicate 1917 or later. I think the US occupation of Vera Cruz ended before that time. I would think it is either Haiti or Cuba sometime 1918-1920

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The USMC incursion into Vera Cruz took place all within the year 1914. However, the USMC occupied the Dominican Republic 1916-1924. Could that be the place?

 

mccooper

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My two cents is Haiti or Dominican Republic. The prisoners don't look (to me) like any pictures I've seen of Vera Cruz.

 

Jon B.

Newaygo MI

Link to comment
Share on other sites

world war I nerd

Thanks for everybody's swags, two cents, opinions and other thoughts.

 

Vera Cruz has definitely been ruled out. However, Haiti, the Dominican Republic (which was my second guess), Cuba & Nicaragua, all still seem to be viable locations for this photo.

 

I was hoping that the "fort" reference might be a clue to anyone who knows the history of these small USMC campaigns, interventions & expeditions better than I do.

 

Teufelhunde.ret., recognized the triangular shaped openings in the wall behind the Marines and prisoners as "gunports", which, of course would be located in a fortification of some sort.

 

Does anyone know if there was a fort in Nicaragua taken, occupied or otherwise used by U.S. Marines as he suggested?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You probably already know this, but in the DR, the Marines captured Fortaleza ar San Francisco de Macoris. Here is a Marine publication about their service there from 1926-1924. Maybe itll provide some other clues. I was trying to find the triangular shaped firing ports.

 

https://www.marines.mil/Portals/59/Publications/Marines%20in%20the%20Dominican%20Republic%20PCN%2019000412600_1.pdf?ver=2012-10-11-164044-497

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You probably already know this, but in the DR, the Marines captured Fortaleza ar San Francisco de Macoris. Here is a Marine publication about their service there from 1926-1924. Maybe itll provide some other clues. I was trying to find the triangular shaped firing ports.

 

https://www.marines.mil/Portals/59/Publications/Marines%20in%20the%20Dominican%20Republic%20PCN%2019000412600_1.pdf?ver=2012-10-11-164044-497

Sorry, its supposed to read 1916-1924.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

world war I nerd

Good work Beast, thanks for the link. I read through most of it and discovered that the provincial capital cities in the Dominican Republic featured something called a "Fortaleza". Printed on page 26, was the following definition of a Fortaleza:

 

Each Dominican provincial capital contains a Fortaleza, a stone built square enclosure, usually with a single ornamented entrance gate. The Fortaleza contains a barracks, offices, an armory, and sometimes a prison and functions as the political as well as military center of provincial government.

 

Based on the above text and the photo below, from the same publication, It's a pretty good guess that the image I posted was taken at an unknown Dominican Fortaleza with prison facilities that had been occupied by U.S. Marines.

 

Thanks to all for sounding off.

post-5143-0-64527000-1534073344_thumb.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 4 years later...

The design of this postcard is indicative of the year, 1914. Postcards after 1914 are indicative with a line in center restricting correspondence on the 1/2 left side.

 

Examples are provided below.

16781216973413733269555426356041.jpg

1678121748343132838108598120262.jpg

16781217724722762941132377956749.jpg

16781217984315903667116331538877.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...